What We Handle

22+ Years Combined UAE Legal Experience

Criminal Breach of Trust

Criminal Breach of Trust in the UAE arises where money, documents, movable property or other assets are handed to a person under a relationship of trust and that person later embezzles, uses or dissipates them in a manner that harms the person entitled to them.

The critical issue is not simply that money is missing or that a commercial relationship has failed.

Under UAE criminal law, the prosecution must examine why the property was handed over, what authority the recipient had, how the property was later used, and whether the conduct satisfies the statutory elements of breach of trust.

This makes Criminal Breach of Trust fundamentally different from ordinary unpaid debt, contractual non-performance or many forms of fraud.

ISN Legal Consultancy assists clients facing these allegations within its broader Criminal Law practice area and Law Firm framework.

What Is Criminal Breach of Trust Under UAE Law?

The UAE Crimes and Penalties Law criminalises the embezzlement, use or dissipation of:

  • funds;
  • written instruments; or
  • other movable property

where those assets were handed to the accused under specified relationships of trust and the conduct causes harm to the person entitled to them.

The statutory relationships include property handed over by way of:

  • trust;
  • lease;
  • mortgage;
  • loan for use; or
  • proxy.

The law also extends the treatment of a proxy to certain other entrusted persons, including someone who receives an object for a specific purpose for the benefit of its owner or another person.

This entrustment element is central to the offence.

The Key Question Is Why the Property Was Handed Over

A Criminal Breach of Trust case should begin with the original transfer.

The prosecution may need to establish:

  1. What property was handed over?
  2. Who owned or was entitled to it?
  3. Why was it entrusted to the accused?
  4. What was the accused permitted to do with it?
  5. What did the accused actually do?
  6. Did that conduct cause harm to the person entitled to the property?

If the property was transferred outright rather than entrusted for a limited purpose, the legal analysis may be very different.

The nature of the original relationship can therefore determine whether the allegation belongs within breach of trust at all.

Breach of Trust vs Ordinary Debt

This distinction is particularly important in commercial disputes.

Suppose Person A transfers AED 100,000 to Person B.

That fact alone does not establish breach of trust.

The legal position may differ depending on whether the AED 100,000 was:

  • a loan;
  • payment for goods;
  • investment capital;
  • money held on behalf of another;
  • funds entrusted for a specific purchase;
  • company money handled under authority; or
  • money transferred under another arrangement.

A person who merely fails to repay an ordinary debt is not automatically guilty of Criminal Breach of Trust.

The prosecution must establish the criminal elements required under UAE law.

Breach of Trust vs Fraud

Criminal Fraud and Criminal Breach of Trust can both involve financial loss, but they are legally different.

Fraud

Fraud generally focuses on deception used to induce the victim to hand over property, money or a legal instrument.

Breach of Trust

Breach of trust generally begins with property being lawfully handed over under a relationship of trust, followed by alleged embezzlement, unauthorised use or dissipation.

The distinction can be summarised as:

Fraud: Was the victim deceived into handing over the property?

Breach of Trust: Was property legitimately entrusted and later misused?

Correct classification can materially affect the defence.

What Does “Entrusted” Mean?

Entrustment generally involves giving another person possession or control for a defined purpose while retaining rights over the property.

Examples may include:

  • giving an employee company funds to make a payment;
  • handing property to an agent to manage or deliver;
  • giving equipment to another person for temporary use;
  • placing money with someone to perform a defined transaction;
  • transferring documents to an authorised representative; or
  • allowing a person to hold property for someone else’s benefit.

The exact contractual or factual arrangement should be examined carefully.

A vague assertion that the accused was “trusted” is not enough by itself.

The legal relationship surrounding the transfer matters.

Misuse Must Go Beyond Mere Possession

The offence concerns conduct such as:

  • embezzling;
  • using; or
  • dissipating

entrusted property in a manner that harms the person entitled to it.

The defence may therefore examine whether the accused:

  • retained the property;
  • spent it;
  • transferred it;
  • sold it;
  • used it outside the permitted purpose;
  • returned part of it;
  • had authority to use it;
  • believed the use was authorised; or
  • can account for what happened.

The central question is what occurred after lawful possession began.

Authority Can Be the Decisive Issue

Many breach-of-trust cases arise because the parties disagree about the scope of authority.

For example, a company director may say:

“I was authorised to use the company funds for operating expenses.”

while the complainant alleges:

“The money was entrusted only for one specific payment.”

The defence may therefore need to examine:

  • contracts;
  • powers of attorney;
  • board resolutions;
  • internal approvals;
  • company policies;
  • emails;
  • WhatsApp messages;
  • accounting practices; and
  • previous transactions.

If the accused acted within genuinely granted authority, the criminal analysis can change significantly.

Criminal Intent Matters

A breach-of-trust allegation should not be assessed only by showing that property was not returned.

The court may need to consider whether the accused deliberately dealt with the entrusted property in a manner inconsistent with the rights of the person entitled to it.

Potentially relevant evidence may include:

  • concealment;
  • false explanations;
  • diversion to personal accounts;
  • sale of property;
  • refusal to account;
  • inconsistent records;
  • attempts to hide transactions; or
  • communications showing the purpose of the transfer.

The defence may rely on evidence showing:

  • genuine mistake;
  • accounting confusion;
  • authorised use;
  • contractual disagreement;
  • unsuccessful commercial performance; or
  • another explanation inconsistent with criminal misappropriation.

Company Funds and Criminal Breach of Trust

Corporate disputes frequently generate breach-of-trust allegations.

Examples may involve:

  • directors;
  • managers;
  • employees;
  • accountants;
  • authorised signatories;
  • business partners;
  • procurement personnel; or
  • agents.

A complaint may allege that company money was:

  • diverted;
  • withdrawn without authority;
  • used personally;
  • paid to related parties;
  • spent outside approved purposes; or
  • concealed from the company.

The defence should reconstruct:

authority → payment → purpose → approval → accounting treatment → benefit received.

This is often more useful than simply asking whether money left the company’s bank account.

Business Partners and Joint Property

The Crimes and Penalties Law expressly treats a partner in jointly owned property as equivalent to a proxy for purposes of the breach-of-trust provision.

This means disputes involving joint assets can potentially create criminal issues where the statutory elements are satisfied.

However, business ownership disputes should still be analysed carefully.

Questions may include:

  • who owned the asset;
  • what share belonged to each party;
  • what management authority existed;
  • what agreement governed use;
  • whether funds were genuinely personal, joint or corporate; and
  • whether the conduct was criminal or merely a civil/accounting dispute.

Partnership disagreement alone does not automatically establish the offence.

Employee Breach of Trust Allegations

Employees may receive company property for legitimate business purposes.

This can include:

  • cash;
  • company cards;
  • inventory;
  • equipment;
  • documents;
  • customer payments; or
  • other company assets.

An allegation may arise where the employer believes the employee:

  • retained customer money;
  • diverted payments;
  • removed inventory;
  • used company funds personally;
  • sold property without permission; or
  • failed to return entrusted equipment.

The employment relationship can provide evidence of authority, but the criminal issue should still be examined separately from disciplinary or employment consequences.

Agents and Powers of Attorney

Agency relationships are especially relevant because Article 453 expressly includes proxy arrangements.

An agent may have authority to:

  • collect money;
  • sell property;
  • make payments;
  • sign documents;
  • manage assets; or
  • carry out another defined transaction.

A breach-of-trust allegation may depend on whether the agent exceeded that authority.

Important evidence may include:

  • power of attorney;
  • agency agreement;
  • instructions;
  • bank transfers;
  • receipts;
  • transaction documents; and
  • communications concerning the purpose of the agency.

Property Given for a Specific Purpose

The law also covers a person who receives an object for use in a specific matter for the benefit of its owner or another person.

This can be particularly important where there is no formal document labelled “trust” or “agency.”

The actual arrangement may still show that:

  • possession was temporary;
  • purpose was defined;
  • ownership remained with another person; and
  • use was restricted.

Courts can therefore look beyond the title of an agreement to the substance of how the property was handed over.

Evidence That Matters in Criminal Breach of Trust Cases

These cases are often document-heavy.

Important evidence may include:

  • contracts;
  • powers of attorney;
  • bank statements;
  • payment instructions;
  • accounting ledgers;
  • invoices;
  • receipts;
  • company resolutions;
  • employment records;
  • internal approvals;
  • email;
  • WhatsApp messages;
  • asset registers;
  • delivery records; and
  • acknowledgments.

The strongest evidence often explains both:

why the property was received

and

what happened to it afterwards.

Bank Transfers Alone May Not Prove Breach of Trust

A bank transfer proves that money moved.

It does not necessarily prove:

  • why it moved;
  • whether ownership changed;
  • whether it was a loan;
  • whether it was an investment;
  • whether it was entrusted;
  • what authority existed; or
  • whether criminal misuse occurred.

The surrounding documents and communications are therefore critical.

A transfer should be connected to the legal relationship that explains it.

Accounting Evidence Can Be Crucial

Where business funds are involved, accounting records may help establish whether:

  • money was booked as a loan;
  • expense was authorised;
  • payment was reimbursable;
  • transaction benefited the company;
  • cash was reconciled;
  • funds were transferred between company accounts; or
  • money was diverted personally.

An accounting irregularity may justify investigation, but it should not automatically be equated with criminal misappropriation.

The legal and accounting evidence must be read together.

Electronic Communications Can Define the Purpose of the Transfer

Messages can sometimes provide the clearest evidence of entrustment.

For example:

“I am sending AED 50,000 for you to pay Supplier X.”

creates a very different evidential picture from:

“Here is your share of the investment.”

A communication may help establish:

  • purpose;
  • authority;
  • repayment expectation;
  • ownership;
  • restrictions; and
  • subsequent explanation.

Complete conversations should be preserved rather than relying only on selected screenshots.

What If the Property Was Eventually Returned?

Return of the property may be relevant to the facts, harm and procedural strategy, but it does not automatically answer whether an offence occurred earlier.

The case should examine:

  • when the property was returned;
  • whether it was returned voluntarily;
  • whether harm had already occurred;
  • whether the complainant had already reported the matter;
  • whether the parties reached settlement; and
  • what UAE law provides for the particular procedural situation.

Repayment should therefore not be treated as an automatic erasure of criminal liability.

Settlement and Criminal Breach of Trust

Financial disputes involving breach-of-trust allegations sometimes lead to settlement.

The parties may agree on:

  • repayment;
  • return of assets;
  • instalments;
  • accounting reconciliation;
  • withdrawal of related civil claims; or
  • another commercial resolution.

However, a private settlement does not automatically terminate every criminal prosecution.

Its legal effect depends on:

  • offence;
  • procedural stage;
  • Criminal Procedures Law; and
  • whether a legally recognised waiver or reconciliation mechanism applies.

The criminal and civil consequences should therefore be considered separately.

Civil Recovery and Criminal Prosecution Can Coexist

A person who loses money or property may have both:

  • a criminal complaint concerning alleged breach of trust; and
  • a civil claim seeking recovery or compensation.

The criminal court focuses on criminal responsibility.

A civil claim focuses on restoration or compensation for loss.

The existence of a civil claim does not automatically prove the crime, and the existence of a criminal complaint does not guarantee recovery of every claimed amount.

Breach of Trust and the Presumption of Innocence

A person accused of Criminal Breach of Trust remains presumed innocent until proven guilty through a legal and fair trial.

Financial disputes often contain strong accusations, but the court must still determine whether the statutory elements are established.

The defence may challenge:

  • existence of entrustment;
  • ownership of the property;
  • scope of authority;
  • alleged misuse;
  • intent;
  • amount;
  • causation of harm; or
  • authenticity and interpretation of evidence.

The accusation itself is not proof.

Practical Criminal Breach of Trust Scenarios

Employee Receives Customer Payments for the Company

If the employee allegedly keeps the money personally, the case may require analysis of entrustment, payment records and what happened to the funds.

Business Partner Uses Joint Funds

The legal position may depend on ownership shares, management authority and whether the use exceeded the partner’s rights.

Agent Sells Property and Retains the Proceeds

The power of attorney and instructions concerning the sale proceeds become central evidence.

Money Is Transferred for a Specific Purchase

If the recipient spends it on something entirely different, the prosecution may examine whether the property was entrusted for that defined purpose.

Investor Loses Money in a Failed Business

Commercial failure alone does not establish breach of trust. The original transaction structure and use of the funds must be analysed.

Manager Is Accused of Personal Use of Company Funds

The defence should examine corporate authority, expense approvals, accounting records and actual benefit derived from the payments.

Common Mistakes in Criminal Breach of Trust Cases

Treating Every Unpaid Amount as Breach of Trust

Ordinary debts require a different analysis.

Ignoring the Original Transfer Agreement

The reason property was handed over is often the central legal issue.

Confusing Fraud With Breach of Trust

Fraud focuses on deception at the point of obtaining property; breach of trust generally concerns misuse after lawful entrustment.

Relying Only on Bank Statements

Bank records show movement of money, not necessarily the legal purpose of the transfer.

Ignoring Authority Documents

Powers of attorney, company resolutions and approvals may determine whether use was authorised.

Assuming Repayment Automatically Ends the Criminal Matter

The legal effect of repayment or settlement depends on the offence and procedural circumstances.

A Strong Criminal Breach of Trust Strategy

A structured case assessment may include:

  1. Identify the property or money allegedly entrusted.
  2. Establish who legally owned or was entitled to it.
  3. Identify the relationship under which it was handed over.
  4. Determine the permitted purpose and authority.
  5. Trace what happened to the asset.
  6. Review banking and accounting records.
  7. Examine electronic communications and instructions.
  8. Assess whether the alleged conduct caused legally relevant harm.
  9. Separate criminal allegations from contractual or civil disputes.
  10. Prepare the evidence for Public Prosecution and, where necessary, Criminal Trial.

The case should be built around the chain of entrustment and alleged misuse rather than simply around the existence of financial loss.

How ISN Legal Consultancy Can Assist with Criminal Breach of Trust Matters

ISN Legal Consultancy assists complainants, accused persons and businesses dealing with breach-of-trust allegations in the UAE.

Assistance may include:

  • reviewing the legal basis of the alleged entrustment;
  • analysing agreements, powers of attorney and company authority;
  • tracing payments and asset movements;
  • reviewing banking and accounting records;
  • distinguishing Criminal Breach of Trust from Criminal Fraud and ordinary civil debt;
  • examining electronic communications;
  • analysing the accused person’s authority and intent;
  • reviewing corporate and partnership disputes;
  • preparing evidence for police and Public Prosecution stages;
  • assisting with Criminal Trial strategy where proceedings continue;
  • assessing related civil recovery issues; and
  • coordinating the matter within ISN Legal Consultancy’s broader Criminal Law and Law Firm framework.

The decisive issue is usually not simply whether property was lost, but whether property was legally entrusted and subsequently dealt with in a manner that satisfies the UAE criminal offence.

Frequently Asked Questions

What Is Criminal Breach of Trust in the UAE?

It generally involves embezzling, using or dissipating money, written instruments or other movable property that was entrusted under a recognised relationship such as trust, lease, mortgage, loan for use or proxy, in a manner causing harm to the person entitled to it.

Is Failure to Repay a Loan Criminal Breach of Trust?

Not automatically. A loan or unpaid debt must be distinguished from property handed over under the type of entrustment covered by the criminal offence.

What Is the Difference Between Fraud and Breach of Trust?

Fraud generally involves deception used to obtain the property in the first place. Breach of trust generally concerns property initially received lawfully and later misused contrary to the purpose of entrustment.

Can a Business Partner Be Accused of Breach of Trust?

Potentially. UAE law expressly addresses partners in jointly owned property within the breach-of-trust provision, but ownership, authority and the specific conduct must still be established.

Can an Employee Face Criminal Breach of Trust Charges?

Potentially, where company money or property was entrusted to the employee and the evidence supports unauthorised embezzlement, use or dissipation satisfying the statutory requirements.

Is a Bank Transfer Enough to Prove Breach of Trust?

No. A transfer may prove movement of money, but other evidence is usually needed to establish why the money was transferred, who was entitled to it and whether it was entrusted.

Does Returning the Money End a Breach of Trust Case?

Not necessarily. Repayment or settlement may be relevant, but its legal effect depends on the facts, offence and procedural position.

Can a Breach of Trust Case Also Include a Civil Claim?

Yes. The alleged victim may potentially pursue compensation or recovery issues alongside or separately from the criminal process, depending on the circumstances and applicable procedure.

Conclusion

Criminal Breach of Trust in the UAE is not simply a legal label for unpaid money or failed business relationships.

The offence is built around entrustment: property must have been handed over under a legally relevant relationship, and the prosecution must establish that it was later embezzled, used or dissipated in a manner causing harm to the person entitled to it.

For both complainants and accused persons, the most important evidence often concerns the original purpose of the transfer, the scope of authority given and the actual movement or use of the property.

ISN Legal Consultancy assists clients with these matters within its broader Criminal Law practice area and Law Firm framework.

Sources